If you want to build a serious literary career, conventional wisdom suggests there is an accepted path. Get an MFA in Creative Writing. The degree is pitched as a career accelerator—a credential that provides two years of focused writing time, a built-in network of agents, and the academic pedigree required to secure a stable university teaching job.
For the writers accepted into fully funded programs, an MFA is often an incredible gift. But for the writers who take out student loans to finance that degree, the decision is far more complex.
When you ask working novelists, literary critics, and university professors about the return on investment (ROI) of a creative writing degree, their advice is nearly unanimous, but heavily nuanced. They acknowledge the immense artistic value of a graduate program, but warn that the publishing industry simply does not pay enough to ever clear that debt.
Here is why established authors warn against the MFA debt trap, and how to weigh the artistic benefits against the stark financial realities.
The Math of the MFA Debt Trap
To understand the financial danger of an unfunded MFA, you have to look at the economic reality of the literary world.
Taking out $40,000, $60,000, or even $80,000 in student loans to attend a prestigious creative writing program means you must eventually pay that money back. In most professions—like law, medicine, or engineering—an advanced degree leads directly to a significantly higher starting salary, allowing the graduate to amortize the debt over time.
The literary industry does not offer this kind of salary bump.
The median advance for a traditionally published book is roughly $12,500. After setting aside money for self-employment taxes and paying a 15 percent commission to a literary agent, the author’s take-home pay is startlingly low. Furthermore, this advance is split into multiple installments paid out over several years.
You cannot service an $80,000 student loan with a $12,500 book advance that takes three years to fully arrive. As one writer and director who took on debt to attend an Ivy League program notes, an MFA is not a guarantee of financial security, just as it is not a guarantee of creative success. In some ways, she admits she was driven to make more money in her corporate career simply because she was terrified of the debt she took on in art school.
The Value of the Credential
It is important to acknowledge that the prestige of certain programs does carry weight outside of the publishing industry. While an elite MFA might not guarantee a massive book deal, it can act as a powerful signal in the corporate world.
One essayist we spoke to left a lucrative advertising career to attend a prestigious New York program, fully aware she would never recoup the cost through her literary writing. However, she realized that an Ivy League degree was legible to corporate America in a way other programs wouldn’t be. She figured if she crashed out and had to beg for her old job back, the gap in her resume to go to art school wouldn’t look as suspicious.
This highlights a crucial nuance. The ROI of an expensive MFA might not come from your art, but from the corporate consulting or copywriting gigs you take to subsidize your art.
The Adjunct Illusion
Many writers justify the cost of an MFA by assuming it will lead to a stable, tenure-track teaching job at a university. This assumption is based on an academic landscape that largely no longer exists.
The reality is that tenure-track jobs in the humanities have been decimated. The vast majority of teaching opportunities available to new MFA graduates are adjunct positions. Adjunct teaching is notoriously unstable, offering poverty-level wages, no health insurance, and no guarantee of future classes.
A professor at a liberal arts college is blunt about this reality. She encourages her undergraduates to only apply to fully funded programs, unless they have independent financial means, because the writing life simply does not offer the financial reward necessary to pay off loans.
Another essayist who left the university system entirely calls adjuncting a scam. He notes that the meager compensation extended to teach a class is in no way worth the material sacrifices required to do it well. While it may not be a complete waste of time for those eager to gain experience, he rarely sees these contingent positions manifest into lasting security.
The “Fully Funded” Rule
Because the financial return on a creative writing degree is so low, working professionals advise aspiring authors to follow a strict rule: only attend an MFA program if it is fully funded.
A fully funded program waives your tuition entirely and provides a living stipend—usually in exchange for teaching undergraduate composition courses or assisting with the university’s literary journal. While these stipends are modest (often hovering around $20,000 to $30,000 a year), they allow the writer to focus on their craft without accumulating crippling debt.
One fiction writer who pursued fully funded graduate programs credits this model with keeping her creative life alive. These programs provide money, time, and space. For her, the only time her writing felt in jeopardy was when she was forced to work a regular office job between degrees.
How to Bypass the MFA Industrial Complex
If you do not get into a fully funded program, and you cannot afford to pay out of pocket, you do not have to abandon your writing career. The industry is full of successful authors who completely bypassed the MFA system.
Instead of paying a university, these writers build their own informal education. They join local, low-cost writing workshops to find community. They read voraciously. They use the money they saved by not going to grad school to attend short-term writing retreats or hire independent developmental editors to critique their manuscripts.
Most importantly, they secure steady day jobs that provide health insurance and a reliable paycheck, protecting their creative energy from financial panic.
As a former Poet Laureate and retired professor advises his students, anything you can do to pay your own bills and keep your head above water while you learn your craft is perfectly fine. Writers have done many things to survive. Not all of them should take the academic route.
Want to know how working writers are paying their bills? Subscribe to the How I Make Money Writing newsletter to read the full archive of over 100 deep-dive interviews with New York Times bestsellers, Pulitzer finalists, freelancer journalists, newsletter operators, and more.
No Comments