Hitting a bestseller list does not guarantee a livable wage, especially if you operate outside the Big Five publishers. Caroline Hagood has published multiple books across poetry, fiction, and memoir, even landing on the Small Press Distribution Best Seller lists. But the royalties from those critically acclaimed indie hits do not pay the rent.
Instead of chasing elusive commercial advances to survive, she engineered a completely different business model. Her financial anchor is a tenure-track teaching position at St. Francis College, supplemented by an administrative role in the college’s teaching and learning center. That stable academic salary acts as the ultimate creative shield, allowing her to write deeply weird, revolutionary hybrid books without constantly worrying about their mass-market viability.
The trade-off for this absolute creative freedom is accepting that the art itself will not pay the bills. Caroline is brutally realistic about her income streams. She works as a Translation Editor for a poetry publisher, a role she freely admits was never designed to generate big money. Even when she scores a massive, grant-funded speaking fee at a university, she treats it as a rare windfall rather than a reliable, recurring paycheck.
By acknowledging that her books will never fully support her or her two children, she removes the crushing expectation that her speculative memoirs need to be commercially lucrative. She lets the work lead, trusting agile indie presses like Santa Fe Writers Project to handle subsidiary rights and distribution while she focuses entirely on the craft.
Surviving this dual life of academia and independent publishing requires a ruthless, highly compartmentalized schedule. She does not have the luxury of silent, month-long writing retreats. Instead, she summons her inner “art monster” in desperate bursts between grading papers, answering interview questions, and playing Monopoly with her kids.
Her daily routine is stripped of all glamour: morning hours are dedicated to lesson planning and editorial duties, while the single hour before she goes to sleep is strictly reserved for writing tasks that absolutely cannot wait. It is an exhausting, unglamorous hustle, but her career proves that if you secure a reliable day job to cover the overhead, you can build a wildly successful literary life entirely on your own terms.
If you want the full picture, including deep dive interviews with 100+ writers where I’ve sat down with authors, poets, ghostwriters, and freelance reporters, alongside New York Times bestsellers, Pulitzer finalists, and Academy Award nominees, make sure you subscribe to How I Make Money Writing.
No Comments