Menu
Business of Writing

How Much Does a Reese’s Book Club Pick Increase Your Next Advance?

Landing a Reese’s Book Club selection and hitting the New York Times bestseller list can allow an author’s literary agent to triple their advance on their next book contract, while also unlocking $2,500 to $50,000 film and television shopping agreements. Across interviews published by How I Make Money Writing, authors share the exact financial impact of celebrity book clubs, journalism awards, and literary prizes.

While a single breakout selection can transform a mid-list thriller novelist into a high-six-figure earner, smaller literary awards often provide career validation and speaking invitations rather than immediate royalty wealth.

How a Reese’s Book Club Pick Tripled Thriller Author Andrea Bartz’s Advance

Thriller novelist Andrea Bartz published multiple books that did not earn out their advances before her breakout novel, We Were Never Here, was selected for Reese’s Book Club and became a New York Times bestseller. That single selection created a massive financial division between her breakout title and the rest of her backlist.

  • Next Book Advance Multiplier: Bartz’s literary agent used the bestseller sales numbers to negotiate an advance three times larger for her subsequent novel.
  • Royalty Concentration: Out of her published novels, We Were Never Here is the only book that earned out its advance and generates ongoing backend royalties.
  • Film and TV Option Range: Screen options and shopping agreements across her work have paid between $2,500 and $50,000 per deal.
  • Income Breakdown: Book advances, royalties, and screen options account for 75 percent of her low-six-figure annual income, with 25 percent coming from consulting and freelance journalism.

Bartz notes that because publishing gangbuster years are followed by slower drafting years, she maintains her author Substack and consulting practice to smooth out cash flow. She details the business mechanics behind her breakout thriller in her full interview with How I Make Money Writing.

Using James Beard Awards to Negotiate Word Counts Instead of Hourly Rates

In nonfiction and journalism, major awards work differently than celebrity book clubs. Environmental journalist and Southlands magazine founder Boyce Upholt has won two James Beard Awards as well as the 2024 Willie Morris Award for Southern Writing for his bestselling book The Great River.

While the Willie Morris Award provided a direct prize-money chunk alongside his book advance installments (in a career where annual earnings swing from -$2,000 to $100,000), Upholt uses his James Beard credentials to pitch editors on longer 8,000-word to 10,000-word feature assignments rather than haggling over small per-word rate bumps. Because his first drafts naturally run long, getting greenlit for higher word counts increases his total payout per story while cutting down editing time, a strategy he explains in his How I Make Money Writing Q&A.

What Literary Prizes and Critical Acclaim Actually Pay Short Story Writers

For literary fiction writers, awards and critical acclaim often unlock speaking fees and agent outreach rather than direct book-sale fortunes.

  • Earning Out a Modest Collection Advance: Environmental attorney Talia Lakshmi Kolluri received an advance under $5,000 for her acclaimed debut story collection, What We Fed to the Manticore. Because the advance was modest, the book sold through within six months, generating steady royalties and $10,000 to $20,000 in annual writing and paid speaking income, as she shares in her full interview.
  • Winning a PEN Short Story Prize on $0 Writing Income: Fiction writer Joanna Demkiewicz won the prestigious PEN/Robert J. Dau Short Story Prize for Emerging Writers, yet she intentionally supports herself through massage therapy and restaurant server shifts rather than putting commercial pressure on her stories, which she discusses in her How I Make Money Writing profile.

Read the Full Financial Breakdowns

Want to see how working novelists, journalists, and poets actually pay their bills? Subscribe to the How I Make Money Writing newsletter to read their archive of 250+ deep-dive interviews with New York Times bestsellers, Pulitzer finalists, indie authors, and freelance writers.

No Comments

    Leave a Reply